Night Mode Night Mode
Day Mode Day Mode

Bungling A’s bitten again by bad defense

Unpolished Oakland defense and solid Kansas City offense turned into another loss for the A’s Sunday afternoon, and equivocally, a sweep by the Royals.

The confounding Athletics, streaky at best and sloppily volatile at worst, lost the final game of their three-game set by a score of 5-3, which was a close 3-2 until Royals catcher Salvador Perez slapped a bomb to left, adding two.

This story has been updated with post-game quotes and additional material from the A’s clubhouse.

Jesse Chavez (L, 4-7, 3.02 ERA), who some could argue was victimized by bad umpiring and substandard defense, allowed three runs in 5-2/3 innings. The argument includes one bad throw from third baseman Max Muncy to catcher Stephen Vogt, which essentially allowed all three Kansas City runs.

With runners at second and third, Perez grounded to Muncy, Mike Moustakas starting from third and trying to advance with the youngster fielding.

Muncy explained:

“Ball was bringing me right in, it was a straight shot to Vogt, and I think I made the right play, I just rushed myself and made a bad throw.”

Muncy’s throw to Vogt was high, though in enough time for the tag to made with any normal throw, but there was no error on the play. That could change, as MLB reviews all questionable calls daily.

Alex Gordon was walked on the next sequence, bringing up outfielder Alex Rios, who is hitting a porous .215 on the season.

Photos by Jeffery Bennett/SFBay

Rios hit a sacrifice fly to center field, scoring Kendrys Morales, who had advanced on the Muncy throw. The sacrifice would have been the third out had any sort of decent throw been made.

The Royals took the lead on an Omar Infante single, scoring Perez, and prompting manager Bob Melvin to take Chavez out of the game.

Melvin summed up the weekend in simple terms:

“We don’t, after five straight wins, lose our intensity and focus. We just got beat. They played better than we did.”

Then he elaborated:

“We think for the most part, their pitching does a good job. Their first two starters threw the ball well. I think we opportunities with Guthrie today. Got his pitch count up, and didn’t look to be as sharp as the first to starters we saw. And then you get to their bullpen and they got a lead, everybody has a tough time with it.”

Muncy, who was clearly frustrated with his day, throwing his helmet to the dirt in disgust after his final at-bat, said:

“We were getting a lot of momentum, we’re playing really good ball lately, and then this happens and it’s against a team like that, that we have a little bit of history with. But it’s more frustrating that we had momentum going as a team and we were playing really good ball.”

Another brutal series of events for the wily veteran, Chavez,, whose statistics fail miserably in telling the truth about how great he’s truly been.

Entering the season, Chavez had a 2.92 FIP score, which measures a pitcher’s effectiveness on a plane without defensive support. Anything below 3.00 is tremendous.

More telling, though, is Chavez’s 1.14 WHIP, which is baserunners allowed per inning, while factoring errors. Anything below 1.20 is pretty darned good.

Except he’s been even better than those numbers say, and major league scouts who have been in attendance through the weekend will likely take note of all the above.

Chavez, who is arbitration-eligible next season and a free agent in 2017, could be moved sooner than Scott Kazmir, who is considered a top tier trade candidate.

Oakland’s offense, though, also failed to perform at a level at which they’re capable Sunday. The team recorded 10 hits and one walk, but failed to get even one-third across the plate.

Royals starter Jeremy Guthrie (W, 6-5, 5.68 ERA) made easy work of the lineup, finishing the painful sixth inning by striking out three batters in order.

Even with shortstop Marcus Semien at second, and Oakland’s best hitter, Stephen Vogt at the plate, Kansas City pitching shut him down and closed out the win.

Oakland went 1-for-6 with runners in scoring position, and left nine runners on throughout the course of the game.

Perhaps the team could have turned the tide of the game, or made it last a little longer, with more offensive power. Perhaps they could have shut out the Royals this weekend, three times in a row, with better defense.

But that’s not what happened.

And with the trade season ready to catch fire, the A’s are not in a position where they look like buyers. And for Kazmir, Chavez, and others, this may become the final week in an A’s uniform.

What’s known now, though, is the A’s will host division foe Seattle for three games, followed by a four-game series versus Colorado.

Follow @SFBay and @LeskiwSFBay on Twitter and at for full coverage of the Oakland Athletics.

Haight Airbnb
Scroll to top