Night Mode Night Mode
Day Mode Day Mode

Man gets 50 years to life for killing Hayward sergeant

A man was sentenced Thursday morning to 50 years to life for killing Hayward Police Sgt. Scott Lunger nearly seven years ago.

In a packed courtroom of family and friends for defendant Mark Estrada as well as police and Lunger’s family, Judge C. Don Clay announced the sentence following a negotiated disposition. The case did not go to trial.

Clay told members of the courtroom:

“Mark Estrada did a senseless act.” 

At about 3:10 a.m. on July 22, 2015, police say Lunger pulled over the then-21-year-old Estrada during a routine traffic stop in a Hayward neighborhood. After Lunger got to Estrada’s vehicle, Estrada shot Lunger in the head.

Estrada’s mother Raquel Estrada said her son plans to appeal.

Mark Estrada made a motion earlier in April to withdraw his no contest plea and Clay denied it, according to the Alameda County District Attorney’s Office.

Raquel Estrada said:

“This is a very bad day for everybody.” 

But she said her son is not violent. She thinks he acted in self-defense. She alleged Lunger was trying to scare her son to make him run.

She said of Mark:

“He’s not a cold-blooded killer.” 

Lunger’s father spoke to members of the courtroom before the sentencing was handed down.

He said what Estrada did has “given us (the family) a life sentence of grief.”

Lunger’s longtime girlfriend said she and Lunger had talked about marriage, calling July 22 the “most horrific day of my life.”

She said:

“Life without Scott is difficult.” 

Detective Justin Green, Lunger’s partner the night he was killed, described Lunger as a leader in the department and a role model for younger officers.

He told courtroom members:

“Scott Lunger meant something to me.” 

He said he feels a sense of failure because Lunger is no longer living. He was at Lunger’s side following the shooting.

Lunger’s daughters also addressed the court, saying their father missed their college graduations and will not be there to walk them down the aisle when they get married.

His youngest daughter said:

“My dad is missing it all.”  

His oldest daughter said her world “was shattered,” adding that Lunger was her coach, mentor, fishing buddy and inspiration, among other things. But she said mostly, he was her “best friend.”

The family did not immediately speak to reporters following the hearing.

Cesar Cruz, who holds a doctorate from Harvard University and is co-founder of Homies Empowerment in Oakland, told members of the courtroom that Hispanic people have a fear of police historically.

Citing former President Donald Trump calling Mexican people rapists, Cruz said: 

“There is a huge climate of fear.” 

Cruz said that doesn’t excuse what Estrada did, but he thinks it’s important to put things into context.

Cruz said:

“I don’t think everything is black and white.”  

He said he didn’t know either Estrada or Lunger.

He said everyone wants all lives to matter, but Black and Hispanic lives seem to matter the least.

Cruz named several Hispanic people killed by police in the Bay Area, including Sean Monterrosa, Erik Salgado and 13-year-old Andy Lopez.

Haight Airbnb
Scroll to top