Protesters shout down SB 50 advocates, say housing bill doesn’t go far enough

State Sen. Scott Wiener, D-San Francisco, came to Oakland on Tuesday to promote a bill that would boost construction of apartment buildings and condominiums in an effort to address the state’s housing shortage.

But Wiener and other speakers at a news conference on the steps of City Hall were drowned out by protesters, including people from the homeless activist group Moms 4 Housing, who said Senate Bill 50 wouldn’t provide enough affordable housing.

Wiener has tried for several years to get the state Legislature to pass his bill, which he said would eliminate restrictive low-density zoning near public transit and job centers and create new zoning standards for those areas.

SB 50 must pass the Senate Appropriations Committee and then the full Senate by the end of January in order to move forward in the new legislative session.

Wiener told reporters after the noisy news conference ended that he’s “cautiously optimistic we will pass this to the Senate floor.”

At the beginning of the news conference, Wiener said the legislation is needed because:

“We have a terrible housing crisis in California.”

Wiener said he recently revised SB 50 to allow for more flexibility in how best to implement the legislation, such as creating a two-year delayed implementation period and allowing cities to craft their own alternative plans that meet the bill’s goals.

He said that under his bill, cities won’t be able to limit density near job or transit centers and will be required to allow small and mid-size apartment buildings.

Wiener said an example is that cities will be able to build taller in one area but shorter in another, or denser in one area but less dense in another.

He said SB 50 guarantees that up to 25 percent of units must be affordable, protects tenants by restricting demolitions of sound housing and has a five-year delayed implementation in low-income communities that are at risk of gentrification.

Oakland Mayor Libby Schaaf, state Sen. Nancy Skinner, D-Berkeley, and other elected officials joined Wiener at the news conference to speak in support of his bill.

But their remarks were mostly drowned out by a large group of housing activists who loudly shouted slogans, such as:

“Affordability — the rent’s too high!” 

“Housing for people, not for profit!”

Other slogans protesters chanted included:

“Give the moms a home today!”  

“Where’s the Affordable Housing?”

When a representative from the California Association of Realtors tried to speak, the protesters booed her and shouted:

“No more speculators!”